Considering Politics, Culture And Nonsense Since 2009

Monday, April 20, 2009

An Interesting Anecdote From Tom Ricks

Tom Ricks, two time contributor to the narrative of the Iraq War (both very much worth the read), makes some interesting comments about the increased numbers of grads of elite colleges and universities joining the military (often entering Officer Candidate School), to which I can also personally attest,

What is going on here? I think two things, one negative, the other historical.

The negative trend is, I think, that a significant portion of students are finishing at our best universities feeling let down and unfulfilled by the experience. It just wasn't all it they'd expected it to be. There is too much drinking and dope-smoking and too little sense of commitment to anything larger than one's own ambitions and appetites. Ultimately, they tell me, they didn't feel challenged to be more than themselves, intellectually or morally.

The historical moment is that these young men are from the 9/11 generation. Most of them were 13 or 14 years old then that attack occurred -- that is, barely conscious of the larger world. Since then, for all their conscious lives, they have lived in a nation at war. So what I think fundamentally is going on is that they are deciding that al Qaeda's attack and its consequences are becoming the defining event of their lifetimes, and they want to be part of that.

No comments:

Post a Comment